Find Your Perfect Eyeliner: The Top 10 Picks for Women

Are you tired of searching for the perfect eyeliner that suits your needs? In this post, I have compiled a list of the top 10 eyeliners that are sure to meet your expectations. Whether you prefer a bold and dramatic look or a subtle and natural one. I have reviewed various brands and types of eyeliners to bring you this comprehensive guide. So, sit back, relax, and let us help you find your perfect eyeliner match.

1. Liquid Eyeliner

When it comes to finding the perfect eyeliner, liquid eyeliners are a popular choice among women. With their smooth application and long-lasting formulas, they can create precise lines and dramatic looks that are sure to make your eyes pop. In this article, we will explore the top 10 picks for liquid eyeliners, including waterproof, felt tip, and brush tip options.

1.1 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

For those who need their eyeliner to stay put all day long, waterproof liquid eyeliners are the way to go. These eyeliners are designed to withstand water, sweat, and humidity, making them perfect for summer days, workouts, or even emotional moments. Their smudge-proof formulas ensure that your eyeliner stays intact without any smearing or running.

Here are some top recommendations for waterproof liquid eyeliners:

Brand X Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner: This highly rated eyeliner offers intense pigmentation and a long-lasting, waterproof formula. Its fine brush tip allows for precise application, making it easy to create both thin and thick lines.
Brand Y Ultra Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner: Known for its ultra-resistant formula, this eyeliner can withstand even the most challenging conditions. Its waterproof formula glides on smoothly and dries quickly, ensuring a flawless finish that lasts all day.

1.2 Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner

Felt tip liquid eyeliners are perfect for those who prefer a controlled and precise application. The felt tip allows for smooth gliding along the lash line, making it easier to create sharp wings or thin lines. These eyeliners are often favored by beginners or those who struggle with applying liquid eyeliner.

Here are some top recommendations for felt tip liquid eyeliners:

Brand Z Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner: This eyeliner features a soft and flexible felt tip that offers excellent control and precision. Its quick-drying formula ensures smudge-proof and long-lasting results. The intense black pigmentation creates a bold and defined look.
Brand W Precision Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner: With its ultra-fine tip, this eyeliner allows for intricate and detailed application. It glides on smoothly without tugging or pulling, providing a seamless finish. The formula is also smudge-proof and long-lasting.

1.3 Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner

Brush tip liquid eyeliners offer versatility and the ability to create various eyeliner styles, ranging from thin and subtle lines to bold and dramatic looks. The brush tip allows for more flexibility, making it easier to experiment with different shapes and thicknesses.

Here are some top recommendations for brush tip liquid eyeliners:

Brand A Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner: This eyeliner features a fine brush tip that offers both precision and control. Its smooth and pigmented formula glides on effortlessly, allowing you to create precise lines or build up for a more intense look. It is also smudge-proof and long-lasting.
Brand B Flexible Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner: Designed with a flexible brush tip, this eyeliner provides a comfortable and easy application. The brush adapts to the natural curve of your eyelid, ensuring a smooth and even line. Its long-wearing formula guarantees a smudge-proof finish.

With the wide range of options available, finding your perfect liquid eyeliner has never been easier. Whether you prefer a waterproof formula, a felt tip for precise application, or a brush tip for versatility, these top 10 picks are sure to cater to your eyeliner needs. Experiment, have fun, and embrace the power of perfectly lined eyes.

2. Pencil Eyeliner

Pencil eyeliners are a popular choice among women due to their versatility and ease of use. They come in a variety of formulas, each offering unique benefits. Whether you prefer a smudge-proof option or a gel pencil eyeliner, there is a perfect pencil eyeliner out there for you.

2.1 Smudge-proof Pencil Eyeliner

Smudge-proof pencil eyeliners are a must-have for women who desire long-lasting and flawless eye makeup. These eyeliners are designed to stay in place throughout the day without smudging or smearing, giving you a perfect look from morning till night.

With their creamy and smooth texture, smudge-proof pencil eyeliners glide effortlessly on your eyelids, allowing for precise application. They are ideal for creating defined lines or achieving a smoky eye effect. Whether you have oily eyelids or live in a humid climate, smudge-proof pencil eyeliners can withstand any challenge, ensuring your makeup stays intact.

When choosing a smudge-proof pencil eyeliner, look for a formula that is waterproof and transfer-resistant. This will ensure that your eyeliner stays put, even in rainy or sweaty conditions. Additionally, opt for a pencil eyeliner that is enriched with ingredients like jojoba oil or vitamin E, as they provide nourishment and hydration to your delicate eye area.

2.2 Gel Pencil Eyeliner

If you’re looking for a pencil eyeliner that offers the intensity and precision of a gel eyeliner, then a gel pencil eyeliner is the perfect choice. These eyeliners combine the ease of application of a pencil with the rich pigmentation and long-lasting power of a gel formula.

Gel pencil eyeliners have a soft and creamy texture that glides smoothly along your lash line, allowing you to create precise and defined lines effortlessly. They offer the versatility to create both thin and thick lines, making them suitable for various eye makeup looks.

One of the major advantages of gel pencil eyeliners is their smudge-proof and waterproof formula. Once applied, they stay in place without smudging, fading, or transferring, giving you a flawless and long-lasting eye makeup look. Additionally, their intense color payoff ensures that your eyes make a bold statement.

When choosing a gel pencil eyeliner, opt for a formula that is quick-drying and long-wearing. This will ensure that your eyeliner sets in place and lasts throughout the day without any touch-ups. Look for a gel pencil eyeliner that is also gentle on the eyes and suitable for sensitive skin.

In conclusion, pencil eyeliners offer a wide range of options for women seeking their perfect eyeliner. Whether you prefer a smudge-proof pencil eyeliner or a gel pencil eyeliner, these versatile products provide the convenience of a pencil with the benefits of different formulas. Choose the pencil eyeliner that suits your needs and preferences, and achieve a stunning eye makeup look effortlessly.

3. Gel Eyeliner

Gel eyeliner is a popular choice among women who want to achieve a bold and long-lasting eye makeup look. This type of eyeliner comes in two different forms: cream gel eyeliner and pot gel eyeliner. Both options offer their own unique benefits and can help you achieve that perfect winged eyeliner or smoky eye look.

3.1 Cream Gel Eyeliner

Cream gel eyeliner is a versatile option that provides a smooth and creamy texture. It typically comes in a small pot or jar, along with a brush for easy application. This type of gel eyeliner is known for its ability to glide on effortlessly, allowing for precise application and control.

One of the advantages of cream gel eyeliner is its long-lasting formula. Once applied, it tends to stay in place for extended periods without smudging or fading. This makes it an excellent choice for those long workdays or special occasions when you want your eye makeup to last all day or night.

Cream gel eyeliner is also highly pigmented, which means you can achieve intense and bold eye looks with just a small amount of product. Whether you prefer a subtle line or a dramatic cat-eye, this type of eyeliner allows for buildable coverage and customization.

3.2 Pot Gel Eyeliner

Pot gel eyeliner, also known as gel pot eyeliner or gel-dip eyeliner, is another popular choice among makeup enthusiasts. This type of gel eyeliner comes in a small pot or container and is typically accompanied by a thin brush for application.

Pot gel eyeliner offers a slightly different texture compared to cream gel eyeliner. It has a thicker consistency, making it ideal for creating precise lines and intricate eye makeup looks. With its smooth and creamy formula, pot gel eyeliner allows for easy gliding and effortless application.

One of the advantages of pot gel eyeliner is its smudge-proof and waterproof properties. Once applied, it sets quickly and stays in place throughout the day, even in humid conditions or during physical activities. This makes it an excellent choice for those who want a long-lasting eyeliner that won’t budge.

Pot gel eyeliner also offers a wide range of color options, allowing you to experiment with different shades and finishes. Whether you prefer a classic black, a vibrant blue, or a shimmery metallic, there is a pot gel eyeliner available to suit your personal style and preferences.

In conclusion, gel eyeliner, whether in the form of cream gel or pot gel, provides a versatile and long-lasting option for achieving a variety of eye makeup looks. Whether you’re going for a subtle everyday look or a bold and dramatic statement, gel eyeliner can help you achieve the perfect finish. Experiment with different formulas and colors to find your ideal gel eyeliner and elevate your eye makeup game.

4. Pen Eyeliner

Eyeliner is an essential makeup product that can instantly elevate your look and create a stunning eye makeup look. Among the various types of eyeliners available in the market, pen eyeliners have gained immense popularity due to their ease of use and precision. Whether you prefer a fine tip or a marker tip, pen eyeliners offer the perfect solution to achieve the desired eye makeup look.

4.1 Fine Tip Pen Eyeliner

Fine tip pen eyeliners are a favorite among makeup enthusiasts who desire precise and intricate eye makeup looks. These eyeliners come with a thin, pointed tip that allows for fine lines and precise application. Whether you want to create a sharp winged eyeliner or a subtle everyday look, a fine tip pen eyeliner can help you achieve it effortlessly.

The advantage of using a fine tip pen eyeliner is the control it offers. The thin tip allows you to have a steady hand and create detailed designs with ease. Additionally, the fine tip ensures that the eyeliner glides smoothly on the eyelids without any smudging or smearing.

4.2 Marker Tip Pen Eyeliner

If you prefer a bolder and more defined eyeliner look, a marker tip pen eyeliner is the perfect choice for you. These eyeliners feature a thicker, marker-like tip that offers more coverage and intensity. The marker tip allows for quick and easy application, making it ideal for those who are new to using eyeliners or prefer a hassle-free makeup routine.

Marker tip pen eyeliners are great for creating bold cat-eye looks or dramatic eyeliner styles. The thicker tip provides a more substantial amount of product, resulting in a more intense and long-lasting finish. Whether you want to achieve a thick, winged eyeliner or a graphic eyeliner design, a marker tip pen eyeliner can help you achieve the desired effect effortlessly.

In conclusion, when it comes to pen eyeliners, you have the option to choose between a fine tip or a marker tip based on your preferred eyeliner style. Whether you want precise lines or bold statements, pen eyeliners offer the versatility and convenience to create your perfect eye makeup look. Experiment with different pen eyeliners to find the one that suits your preferences and enjoy the endless possibilities they offer for enhancing your eyes.

5. Kohl Eyeliner

When it comes to eyeliner, kohl is a popular choice among women for its versatility and intense pigmentation. Kohl eyeliners have been used for centuries in various cultures and are known for their ability to create dramatic and smoky eye looks. In this section, we will explore two popular types of kohl eyeliners: smoky kohl eyeliner and soft kohl eyeliner.

5.1 Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

Smoky kohl eyeliner is perfect for creating a sultry and mysterious look. This type of eyeliner is typically darker and has a softer texture compared to regular kohl eyeliners. The smudgy and blendable formula of smoky kohl eyeliner allows for easy application and effortless smudging, making it ideal for achieving that coveted smoky eye effect.

To apply smoky kohl eyeliner, start by lining your upper and lower lash lines with short strokes. Then, gently smudge the liner using a smudging brush or your fingertip to soften the edges and create a smoky effect. You can also use an angled brush to blend the liner into your eyeshadow for a seamless finish. Smoky kohl eyeliners are available in a range of shades, from classic black to deep browns and even rich jewel tones, allowing you to experiment with different looks.

5.2 Soft Kohl Eyeliner

If you prefer a more subtle and natural look, soft kohl eyeliner is the way to go. This type of eyeliner has a creamy and smooth texture that glides effortlessly on the skin, making it suitable for those with sensitive eyes or who prefer a gentler application. Soft kohl eyeliners are often formulated with nourishing ingredients like oils and waxes to provide hydration and prevent smudging throughout the day.

To apply soft kohl eyeliner, gently draw a thin line along your upper lash line, starting from the inner corner towards the outer corner. You can also extend the liner slightly past the outer corner of your eyes for a subtle winged effect. If desired, repeat the process on your lower lash line, keeping the line thin and close to the lashes for a natural look. Soft kohl eyeliners are available in various shades, including classic black, brown, and even softer hues like taupe and gray, allowing you to enhance your eyes without overpowering your overall makeup look.

In conclusion, kohl eyeliners offer a wide range of options for women looking to find their perfect eyeliner. Whether you prefer a smoky and dramatic look or a soft and natural one, smoky kohl eyeliner and soft kohl eyeliner are two excellent choices to consider. Experiment with different techniques and shades to find the kohl eyeliner that best complements your unique style and enhances the beauty of your eyes.

6. Cake Eyeliner

When it comes to finding your perfect eyeliner, cake eyeliner is a classic choice that offers versatility and long-lasting wear. Whether you prefer a more traditional application or a wet and dry formula, cake eyeliner has got you covered. In this section, we will explore two variations of cake eyeliner: classic cake eyeliner and wet & dry cake eyeliner.

6.1 Classic Cake Eyeliner

Classic cake eyeliner is a timeless option that has been used for decades to create stunning eye looks. This type of eyeliner typically comes in a compact form, consisting of a pressed powder that can be activated with water or a mixing medium. The texture of classic cake eyeliner is smooth and velvety, allowing for precise application and easy blending.

One of the advantages of using classic cake eyeliner is that it offers intense pigmentation, making it perfect for achieving dramatic eye makeup looks. Whether you prefer a thin and subtle line or a bold and thick cat-eye, classic cake eyeliner can help you achieve the desired effect effortlessly.

To apply classic cake eyeliner, simply dampen an eyeliner brush or an angled brush and swirl it into the product to create a creamy consistency. Then, starting from the inner corner of your eye, gently glide the brush along your lash line, gradually building up the thickness and intensity as desired. The creamy texture of the eyeliner allows for smooth and precise application, ensuring a flawless finish.

6.2 Wet & Dry Cake Eyeliner

For those who prefer a more versatile option, wet & dry cake eyeliner is an excellent choice. This type of eyeliner offers the convenience of using it both wet and dry, allowing you to customize your eye look according to your preference and the occasion.

When used dry, wet & dry cake eyeliner provides a soft and subtle effect, perfect for creating natural-looking eye makeup. Simply apply the product using an eyeliner brush or a smudging brush, and gently sweep it along the lash line for a defined yet understated look. This technique works particularly well for everyday makeup or for those who prefer a more minimalistic approach.

On the other hand, when used wet, this type of cake eyeliner transforms into a bolder and more vibrant formula, ideal for creating intense and striking eye looks. By dampening your brush before applying the product, you can achieve a more saturated and dramatic result. This wet application method is perfect for special occasions or when you want to make a statement with your eye makeup.

The versatility of wet & dry cake eyeliner makes it a must-have in any makeup collection. Whether you’re going for a subtle or a bold look, this eyeliner can adapt to your needs and help you achieve the perfect eye makeup look every time.

In conclusion, cake eyeliner offers a range of options to suit your eyeliner preferences. From the classic cake eyeliner for a timeless and intense look to the wet & dry cake eyeliner for versatile and customizable effects, these variations provide long-lasting wear and endless possibilities for creating stunning eye makeup looks. Experiment with different techniques and unleash your creativity to find your perfect eyeliner style.

7. Cream Eyeliner

When it comes to achieving a flawless eye makeup look, cream eyeliners are an essential tool for every woman. Their smooth and creamy texture allows for easy application and precise lines, making them a popular choice among makeup enthusiasts. In this section, we will explore two types of cream eyeliners that are worth considering for your makeup collection: long-wearing cream eyeliner and gel cream eyeliner.

7.1 Long-wearing Cream Eyeliner

If you’re someone who prefers a long-lasting eyeliner that can withstand the demands of a busy day, then a long-wearing cream eyeliner is the perfect choice for you. This type of cream eyeliner is formulated to have exceptional staying power, ensuring that your eye makeup stays intact for hours on end.

Long-wearing cream eyeliners are known for their smudge-proof and waterproof properties, making them ideal for those with oily eyelids or for occasions when you need your makeup to last all day or night. They are specially designed to resist smudging, fading, or smearing, providing you with a sharp and defined eye look that stays put throughout the day.

To apply a long-wearing cream eyeliner, you can use an angled brush or a fine-tipped eyeliner brush for precise application. The creamy consistency of these eyeliners allows for easy gliding along the lash line, making it effortless to create various eye looks, from subtle to dramatic.

7.2 Gel Cream Eyeliner

For those who desire intense pigmentation and a smooth application, gel cream eyeliners are a fantastic option. These eyeliners combine the best qualities of both gel and cream formulas, resulting in a highly pigmented and long-lasting eyeliner that glides on effortlessly.

Gel cream eyeliners usually come in a pot or a compact, accompanied by a brush for application. The texture of these eyeliners is rich and creamy, allowing for easy control and precision during application. They are renowned for their ability to create bold and dramatic eye looks, making them a favorite among makeup artists and enthusiasts alike.

One of the key advantages of gel cream eyeliners is their versatility. They can be used to create a variety of eye makeup styles, including thin and precise lines or smoky and smudged effects. Additionally, their long-lasting formula ensures that your eye makeup remains intact for extended periods, making them suitable for special events or long days.

In conclusion, cream eyeliners offer a smooth and creamy consistency that allows for easy application and precise lines. Whether you opt for a long-wearing cream eyeliner for all-day wear or a gel cream eyeliner for intense pigmentation, these products are sure to enhance your eye makeup game. Experiment with different techniques and styles to find the perfect cream eyeliner that suits your preferences and helps you achieve stunning eye looks.

8. Powder Eyeliner

Powder eyeliner is a popular choice among makeup enthusiasts for its versatility and ease of application. This type of eyeliner comes in two forms: loose powder eyeliner and pressed powder eyeliner.

8.1 Loose Powder Eyeliner

Loose powder eyeliner offers a wide range of colors and finishes, making it a go-to option for those who love experimenting with different looks. The loose formulation allows for easy blending and smudging, giving you the freedom to create a variety of eye makeup styles.

One of the advantages of using loose powder eyeliner is its ability to create a soft and smoky effect. By using an angled brush or an eyeliner brush, you can easily apply the loose powder along your lash line and then smudge it for a more dramatic look. This type of eyeliner is also great for achieving a gradient effect by layering different shades.

To ensure long-lasting wear, it’s recommended to apply an eyeshadow primer before using loose powder eyeliner. This will help the powder adhere to your eyelids and prevent it from smudging or fading throughout the day. Additionally, using a setting spray can further enhance the longevity of your powder eyeliner.

8.2 Pressed Powder Eyeliner

Pressed powder eyeliner is a compact version of powder eyeliner, making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. The pressed formulation provides a more precise and defined application, perfect for achieving a clean and polished look.

Unlike loose powder eyeliner, pressed powder eyeliner typically comes in a single shade or a limited color range. This makes it a great option for those who prefer a classic and timeless eyeliner look.

To apply pressed powder eyeliner, use an eyeliner brush or an angled brush to pick up the product and gently press it along your lash line. The compact nature of pressed powder eyeliner allows for better control and precision, resulting in a well-defined line.

Similar to loose powder eyeliner, using an eyeshadow primer prior to application can help prolong the wear of pressed powder eyeliner. Additionally, setting the eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow can help prevent smudging and ensure a long-lasting finish.

In conclusion, powder eyeliner, whether in loose or pressed form, offers a versatile and easy-to-use option for enhancing your eye makeup. Whether you’re aiming for a soft and smoky look with loose powder eyeliner or a precise and defined line with pressed powder eyeliner, this type of eyeliner provides endless possibilities for creating your perfect eye look.

9. Winged Eyeliner

Winged eyeliner is a popular makeup trend that adds a touch of glamour and sophistication to any look. Whether you prefer a subtle flick or a dramatic wing, mastering the art of winged eyeliner can elevate your makeup game to the next level. In this section, we will explore two variations of winged eyeliner: flicked winged eyeliner and dramatic winged eyeliner.

9.1 Flicked Winged Eyeliner

Flicked winged eyeliner is a classic and timeless style that suits various eye shapes and sizes. It involves creating a small flick at the outer corner of the eye, giving the illusion of a lifted and elongated eye shape. Here are some tips to achieve the perfect flicked winged eyeliner look:

Start by applying a thin line of eyeliner along your upper lash line, starting from the inner corner and gradually thickening it towards the outer corner.
Once you reach the outer corner of your eye, angle the eyeliner brush or pen upwards towards the end of your eyebrow.
Use a light hand to create a small flick, extending it slightly beyond the natural lash line.
Connect the flick to the rest of the eyeliner, creating a seamless line.
If you want a more pronounced flick, you can extend it further or make it thicker.

Flicked winged eyeliner is perfect for day-to-day wear and can be easily adjusted to achieve a subtle or more noticeable effect. Experiment with different eyeliner formulas, such as liquid, gel, or pen, to find the one that suits your preferences and skill level.

9.2 Dramatic Winged Eyeliner

For those seeking a bolder and more dramatic look, dramatic winged eyeliner is the way to go. This style involves creating a more pronounced and elongated wing, making a statement with your eye makeup. Here’s how you can achieve a dramatic winged eyeliner look:

Begin by applying a thicker line of eyeliner along your upper lash line, starting from the inner corner and extending it towards the outer corner.
Instead of creating a small flick, continue the line in a straight or slightly curved upward motion, depending on the desired effect.
Extend the wing beyond the outer corner of your eye, aiming for a more dramatic and elongated shape.
For added intensity, you can make the line thicker or create a double-winged effect by drawing a parallel line above the initial wing.
Ensure both wings are symmetrical by comparing and adjusting as needed.

Dramatic winged eyeliner is a great choice for special occasions, evening events, or when you want to make a bold statement with your eye makeup. Experiment with different eyeliner textures, such as matte, glossy, or metallic, to create unique and eye-catching looks.

Remember, practice makes perfect when it comes to winged eyeliner. Don’t be discouraged if it takes a few tries to achieve your desired look. With time and patience, you’ll become a pro at creating flawless winged eyeliner styles that enhance your natural beauty.

10. Colored Eyeliner

Colored eyeliner is a fun and creative way to enhance your eye makeup look. Whether you prefer a bold and vibrant shade or a subtle metallic sheen, there are plenty of options to choose from. In this article, we will explore two types of colored eyeliner: vibrant colored eyeliner and metallic colored eyeliner.

10.1 Vibrant Colored Eyeliner

Vibrant colored eyeliner adds a pop of color to your eyes and can instantly elevate your makeup game. Whether you want to make a statement or simply experiment with a new look, vibrant colored eyeliner is the way to go. Here are some top picks for vibrant colored eyeliners:

Electric Blue: This striking shade of blue brings out the natural beauty of your eyes and adds a touch of drama to your overall look.
Emerald Green: For a bold and enchanting look, emerald green eyeliner is the perfect choice. It complements all eye colors and adds a mesmerizing touch to your makeup.
Purple Passion: If you want to make your eyes stand out, opt for a vibrant purple eyeliner. This shade creates a captivating and alluring effect.

Experimenting with vibrant colored eyeliner allows you to step out of your comfort zone and embrace your unique style. With these top picks, you can easily find the perfect vibrant colored eyeliner to suit your preferences.

10.2 Metallic Colored Eyeliner

If you’re looking to add a touch of glamour and sophistication to your eye makeup, metallic colored eyeliner is the way to go. These eyeliners have a shimmery finish that catches the light and creates a stunning effect. Here are some top picks for metallic colored eyeliners:

Golden Goddess: A metallic gold eyeliner instantly adds a touch of luxury to your eyes. It complements warm-toned skin and creates a radiant and glamorous look.
Silver Lining: For a cool and futuristic vibe, opt for a metallic silver eyeliner. It brightens up your eyes and adds a modern twist to your makeup.
Bronze Beauty: If you want a warm and sultry look, go for a metallic bronze eyeliner. This shade adds depth and dimension to your eyes, making them look mesmerizing.

Metallic colored eyeliner is perfect for special occasions or when you want to make a statement. These top picks offer a range of colors that suit different skin tones and eye colors, allowing you to find the perfect metallic eyeliner for any occasion.

In conclusion, colored eyeliner adds a unique and playful touch to your eye makeup look. Whether you prefer vibrant shades or metallic finishes, there are plenty of options to choose from. Experiment with different colors and styles to find your perfect eyeliner and elevate your makeup game.